4 Comments
User's avatar
Ciaran's avatar

Time to get rid of MMP - check out electoralreform.nz - all of these discussions overlook the fact that 56% of our MPs - the electorate ones - are still elected under FPP and we may have any number of them elected with minority votes - Mt Albert is suggested that it may elect national with only 29% of the votes. Also MMP is getting gamed as pointed out in this podcast and nothing is going to change while half of our MPs owe their comfortable seat in parliament to the status quo

Michael Swanson's avatar

My fear is that any attempt to "get rid" if MMP is that you just end up back with FPP. I think at this stage reform of MMP is a much more manageable and palatable approach, but as I mentioned I'd prefer to move to an Open List system like Sweden. No electorates, no problem!

Richard Santillan's avatar

The 2012 review's recommendation to abolish overhang outright was essentially a proposal to prevent that sort of corruption. It wasn't adopted, and here we are.

Michael Swanson's avatar

I think one of the most bizarre aspects of MMP is the coat-tailing rule (an extra seat if you get 1.5%, and so on). How they didnt envisage issues with that and overhang, and then decided never to touch them has always puzzled me.

Our biggest issue, though, is the turkeys voting for Christmas situation. The political will needed to make changes is just so lacking unless it provides a direct benefit to them.