The Kākā by Bernard Hickey

Share this post
Dawn chorus: An invidious and unfair debt lid
thekaka.substack.com

Dawn chorus: An invidious and unfair debt lid

Wellington Council should lift its self-imposed debt 'lid' from 225% of revenue to at least the LGFA's self-imposed limit of 300%; Councils also need more revenue linked directly to population growth

Bernard Hickey
Mar 3, 2021
1
Share this post
Dawn chorus: An invidious and unfair debt lid
thekaka.substack.com

TLDR: The central Government and ratepayers have put themselves and Councils in an invidious and unfair position where out-of-date and arbitrary rules about debt are stopping councils from addressing their massive housing affordability and climate change challenges.

All over the country, the pressure of decades of under-investment in infrastructure, much faster than expected and planned-for population growth, and these debt limits, are putting councils in the growth cities (Auckland, Hamilton, Tauranga, Wellington, Queenstown and Christchurch) under enormous financial and social pressure. Some of these limits are self-inflicted and ideological, but often councillors, Mayors and ratepayers simply haven’t been advised about how the worlds of bond investors, interest rates and central bank bond-buying have changed dramatically since those limits were set.

Understandably, councils are cracking at the seams under that pressure. Tauranga’s Mayor Tenby Powell resigned and called in a commissioner after the scale of the infrastructure building overwhelmed the Council, forcing it to prepare for double-digit rates increases. Councillors elected on rates restriction platforms rebelled and chaos ensued, in part because councils don’t have the same party, parliamentary and cabinet disciplines that voters are used to on the national stage.

Auckland is the biggest and also under pressure as Covid-19 hit its revenues and therefore reduced its ability to borrow up to the 300% of revenue limit set by the Local Government Funding Agency, which borrows in bond markets on behalf of 91 Councils. Only Napier and Dunedin don’t use the LGFA. Auckland has launched a ludicrous round of austerity and cost-cutting because it fears its revenue to debt ratio might trigger a credit rating downgrade. It fears that might cause a sovereign downgrade, which would in turn push up longer term interest rates.

That assumption is questionable in various ways, but espcially now that Standard and Poor’s has just upgraded New Zealand’s sovereign rating to AAA.

Now the focus is on Wellington today where the Mayor Andy Foster pushed to sell or lease half the library and cancel some new cycleways just so the Council could keep under its own self-imposed debt limit of 225%. The Council should at least lift that limit to the 300% limit set by LGFA and then start challenging the entire focus on debt limits and debt affordability.

The reason: LGFA has raised about $2b on behalf of councils since the onset of Covid-19 with an average interest rate of 0.99 percent, and the Reserve Bank bought $1.75b worth of those and other LGFA bonds at an average interest rate of 0.76%. The Reserve Bank actually needs councils to borrow a lot more than they are, and it has their back. Here’s what its intervention in March did to borrowing costs.

Wellington Council should lift its self-imposed debt 'lid' from 225% of revenue to at least the LGFA's self-imposed limit of 300%. Councils also need more revenue linked directly to population growth, potentially through GST rebates on rates and building materials, and forcing Government agencies to pay rates.

Elsewhere in our political economy

Twitter avatar for @bernardchickeyBernard Hickey @bernardchickey
In which the @FT criticises NZ's housing policy. 'Central banks make a convenient scapegoat for politicians who are unwilling to take on the vested interests that can create an artificial scarcity of housing even in a land-rich country such as NZ'
Subscribe to read | Financial TimesNews, analysis and comment from the Financial Times, the worldʼs leading global business publicationft.com

March 3rd 2021

1 Retweet
Twitter avatar for @coughlthomThomas Coughlan @coughlthom
Some of the most interesting OIAs I’ve ever read: In April, the Government explored food rationing, closing supermarkets and blocking exports and even modelled a $30b wage subsidy in its worst case scenarios.
Longer lockdowns, $30b wage subsidy, and food rationing in Covid worst-case scenarioTougher restrictions than level 4, longer lockdowns, food rationing, and blocking exports were all considered by the Government.i.stuff.co.nz

March 3rd 2021

3 Retweets6 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NZStuffPoliticsStuff.co.nz Politics @NZStuffPolitics
Government cut $239m from proposed $1 billion water bailout fund for councils
Government cut $239m from proposed $1 billion water bailout fund for councilsGovernment proposal was for $1 billion pipes fund - but that was slashed to $761m.dlvr.it

March 3rd 2021

Twitter avatar for @NZStuffBusinessStuff.co.nz Business @NZStuffBusiness
Staff complain that 'pandemic clauses' are leaving them without pay
Staff complain that ‘pandemic clauses’ are leaving them without payWorkers baulk at being left unpaid or under-paid because of their contracts.dlvr.it

March 3rd 2021

Twitter avatar for @TheSpinoffTVThe Spinoff @TheSpinoffTV
New Zealand has no plan yet for how to vaccinate 98% of the population
New Zealand’s Covid-19 vaccine programme is still largely a secretThe government has released few details about this country’s Covid-19 vaccine programme as it progresses. Overseas, meanwhile, countries are increasingly ambitious in their public goals to get jabs out. Justin Giovannetti reports. New Zealand’s vaccine programme will move to its second stage nextthespinoff.co.nz

March 3rd 2021

Twitter avatar for @JeneeTibshraenyJenée Tibshraeny @JeneeTibshraeny
Westpac NZ Chief Economist Dominick Stephens is taking up a 10-month secondment later this month as Treasury’s Deputy Secretary, Chief Economic Advisor.

March 3rd 2021

1 Retweet29 Likes
Twitter avatar for @rnz_newsRNZ News @rnz_news
Dirty Politics: Saga ends with Carrick Graham apology in court
Dirty Politics: Saga ends with Carrick Graham apology in courtOne of the last acts of the Dirty Politics saga has come to a dramatic end in court today with lobbyist Carrick Graham apologising for spreading defamatory statements about three public health advocates.rnz.co.nz

March 3rd 2021

24 Retweets72 Likes

In the global political economy

Twitter avatar for @OBR_UKOffice for Budget Responsibility @OBR_UK
The tax rises announced in #Budget2021 increase the tax burden to 35 per cent of GDP in 2025-26, its highest level since Roy Jenkins was Chancellor in the late 1960s
Image

March 3rd 2021

49 Retweets43 Likes
Twitter avatar for @michaelujacobsMichael Jacobs @michaelujacobs
50 academic economists say in a letter to The Times today that raising taxes and cutting spending to repay debt because it is going above 100% of GDP would be 'economically illiterate'. We need a green, care-led fiscal stimulus today. (Behind a paywall, hence photo!)
Image

March 3rd 2021

252 Retweets517 Likes

Signs o’ the times news

Twitter avatar for @coughlthomThomas Coughlan @coughlthom
National could turn opposition to "cancel culture" into a winning issue said pollster David Farrar according to a leaked account of a National Party meeting last night
‘Wokester’, cancel culture issue a winner for National, says party pollsterThe National Party’s pollster told MPs cancel culture issues were winning them support.stuff.co.nz

March 3rd 2021

2 Retweets10 Likes

Charts of the day

Twitter avatar for @brendon_harreBrendon Harre @brendon_harre
New Zealand is really bad at housing its people
Image

March 3rd 2021

72 Retweets274 Likes
Twitter avatar for @brendon_harreBrendon Harre @brendon_harre
And if you thought the house price situation was bad. The rental situation in New Zealand is even worse.
Image

March 3rd 2021

27 Retweets89 Likes

Weekend reads or listens

Twitter avatar for @karlazabsKarlaZabs @karlazabs
He's Mexico's second richest man, partying his way through the pandemic, while his workers are dying of COVID-19. A Twitter troll, an in-your-face bon vivant. He loves to be hated. His victims are desperate. “He is so powerful and I... trash,” said one.
This Billionaire Has Been Partying Through the Pandemic While His Company’s Workers DiedRicardo Salinas Pliego has seen his net worth rise to $13.5 billion during the pandemic. But while he’s partied on his yacht, his workers have faced deadly conditions that violate Mexico’s pandemic rubuzzfeednews.com

March 2nd 2021

143 Retweets216 Likes

Twitter avatar for @businessdesk_nzBusinessDesk_NZ @businessdesk_nz
.@Peter_J_Beck on shotguns, Starlink, and the state of NZ’s entrepreneurs: "I liken running a rocket company to running through the maze at night, and at every dead end there’s a guy with a shotgun." @hrburrell
Peter Beck on shotguns, Starlink, and the state of NZ’s entrepreneursPeter Beck this week led Rocket Lab, the company he founded in New Zealand in 2006, to a US$4.1 billion market valuation.His analogy for how he got to this point sounds like something from a first-person shooter video game. “I liken running a rocket company to running through the maze at …businessdesk.co.nz

March 3rd 2021

2 Retweets4 Likes

PPS Some fun things

Twitter avatar for @GurdeepPandherGurdeep Pandher of Yukon @GurdeepPandher
Yesterday evening I received my Covid-19 vaccine. Then I went to a frozen lake to dance Bhangra on it for joy, hope and positivity, which I'm forwarding across Canada and beyond for everyone's health and wellbeing.
Image

March 2nd 2021

14,349 Retweets101,219 Likes
Twitter avatar for @Tim_BattTim Blart Malt Cup @Tim_Batt
You can track my lockdown mental decline on the average number of tabs I have open at any given time. There is a DIRECT coloration between my computer's RAM usage and my likelihood to stop bathing.

March 3rd 2021

26 Likes
Twitter avatar for @cjsbishopChristopher Bishop @cjsbishop
Can't be Sir Brian as he is already chair of NZTA. So Heather Simpson where are you?
Let’s Get Wellington Moving to be overhauled with new independent chairLast month a scathing review of the $6.4 billion programme found it at risk of failure, under-resourced and with a detrimental culture.rnz.co.nz

March 3rd 2021

1 Retweet6 Likes
Share this post
Dawn chorus: An invidious and unfair debt lid
thekaka.substack.com
Comments

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Bernard Hickey
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing